Yes, there are alternative approaches to sharing common code in Google Cloud Dataform without using public or private npm packages. Here are two common alternatives:
Git Submodules: A Version-Controlled Approach with Dynamic Updates
Git submodules allow embedding a Git repository as a subdirectory within another repository, facilitating the integration of shared code into multiple Dataform projects.
Steps:
- Shared Repository Creation: Establish a separate Git repository for the shared code.
- Shared Code Development: Develop common functions and variables within this repository.
- Submodule Integration: Add the shared repository as a submodule in each Dataform repository requiring the shared code (
git submodule add <repository-url> <path/to/submodule>).
- Code Referencing: Utilize the shared code in your Dataform files via the submodule path.
Advantages:
- Version Control: Ensures consistency across projects with controlled versioning.
- Encapsulation: Maintains shared code in its own repository, promoting modularity.
- Synchronization: Reflects code changes across repositories through submodule updates.
- Branch Tracking: Tracks specific branches for dynamic updates.
- Collaboration and Code Review: Facilitates independent review and management of shared code.
Disadvantages:
- Complexity: Managing multiple repositories can be challenging.
- Manual Updates: Requires manual intervention for updating submodules.
JavaScript Modules: A Direct Import Approach with Dynamic SQL Generation
Dataform's support for importing JavaScript modules directly into SQL files allows for the integration of common functions and variables into SQL workflows.
Steps:
- JavaScript Module Creation: Develop JavaScript files with common code.
- Module Placement: Store these files in a dedicated directory within the Dataform repository.
- Code Import: Import the modules into Dataform SQL files using the
import statement.
Advantages:
- Clean Code Structure: Promotes an organized code setup.
- No External Repositories: Simplifies code management without separate repositories.
- Automatic Updates: Directly reflects code changes in Dataform files.
- Integration with SQLX: Enables dynamic SQL query generation and complex logic implementation.
- Simplified Dependency Management: Manages dependencies more straightforwardly within the same repository.
Disadvantages:
- Manual Change Propagation: Requires manual updates across importing files.
- Version Control Discipline: Necessitates disciplined version control for consistency.
Additional Considerations:
- Documentation and Best Practices: Essential for smooth collaboration and maintenance.
- Security and Access Control: Critical for managing sensitive or proprietary code, especially in regulated environments.
- Flexibility and Scalability: Git submodules suit larger projects or teams, while JavaScript modules are preferable for smaller, agile teams.
- CI/CD Integration: Both methods support automated testing and deployment.
- Testing Strategies: Facilitates different testing approaches; integration testing for Git submodules and unit testing for JavaScript modules.
- Versioning in JavaScript Modules: Internal versioning schemes or repository tagging can manage different code versions.
- Learning Curve: Requires understanding Git for submodules and JavaScript module syntax for direct imports.
The choice between Git submodules and JavaScript modules in Google Cloud Dataform hinges on various factors, including team preferences, project structure, and existing workflows. It's crucial to weigh the pros and cons of each method in the context of specific requirements and team capabilities. Effective code sharing is key to maintaining a consistent, reusable, and maintainable codebase across Dataform projects. Careful evaluation of each method's nuances is essential to select the one that best suits your team's needs.
LinkedIn
Twitter
