Get hands-on experience with 20+ free Google Cloud products and $300 in free credit for new customers.

Intermittent DB connections of CloudSQL on postgres

We’re facing a persistent issue with our database connections, and it's causing significant disruptions to our application. Around a specific time, all database connections drop simultaneously, and we see the following error in the logs:

ALERT 2024-11-29T07:46:48.125540Z 2024-11-29 07:46:44.437 UTC [1129439]: [2-1] db=REDACTED,user=REDACTED FATAL: connection to client lost

During this time, the database latency increases drastically, rendering the app unresponsive and eventually causing it to crash. However, the connections automatically re-establish after some time without any manual intervention.

Our backend is built with Python Django, and we currently don’t use connection pooling. From my analysis, since all connections are dropping, and there are no notable CPU or memory spikes causing it, connection reuse or pooling wouldn’t fully resolve the issue. It feels like something deeper is at play.

Has anyone encountered a similar issue or have any insights into potential causes or fixes? Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

Screenshot 2024-11-19 at 12.26.19.png



0 1 214
1 REPLY 1

It seems the connection drops and associated issues can be attributed to several potential causes. A systematic analysis reveals a clear pattern in the data: high request volumes (approximately 400-600 hits) are followed by a sudden drop in activity. Additionally, there is a significant latency spike, with p95 latency increasing to nearly 4 minutes immediately prior to the connection failures. Notably, this behavior appears cyclical, as connections are re-established automatically after a brief disruption. Such observations strongly suggest external factors, including maintenance activities, resource limits, or network disruptions.

A possible cause might be Cloud SQL’s maintenance window. Cloud SQL instances are occasionally subject to automated maintenance for updates or failover testing, which can temporarily disrupt connectivity. This aligns with the cyclical nature of the observed pattern. Additionally, connection limits may also play a role. Without a connection pooling mechanism in place, high simultaneous connections could lead to the exhaustion of Cloud SQL’s max_connections limit, causing new connections to fail and existing ones to timeout. Furthermore, the simultaneous drop of all connections hints at a potential network-level issue. This could involve changes in the VPC configuration, misconfigured Cloud SQL Proxy settings, or updates to firewall rules and security policies that momentarily interrupt connectivity.

To address these issues, implementing connection pooling is highly recommended. Connection pooling helps manage database connections efficiently by reusing existing connections, reducing churn, and providing better error handling. For Django, tools such as PgBouncer or django-db-geventpool can be integrated to establish a more robust connection management framework. For instance, with django-db-geventpool, you can configure parameters like MAX_CONNS to set the maximum number of connections in the pool and REUSE_CONNS to define how many times a connection can be reused before being reset. This setup reduces connection overhead and improves overall application stability.

Another critical step is to investigate whether Cloud SQL maintenance activities coincide with the observed connection drops. You can access the maintenance history via the Google Cloud Console under Operations → Cloud SQL → Maintenance History. If maintenance activities align with the timing of connection drops, you may need to adjust your application’s downtime tolerance or schedule maintenance during off-peak hours. Additionally, enabling email notifications for upcoming maintenance can help you proactively prepare for such events. To further explore maintenance-related configurations, querying PostgreSQL settings with a command like SELECT name, setting FROM pg_settings WHERE name LIKE '%maintenance%'; can provide valuable insights.

Monitoring active and idle connections is equally essential to ensure that the max_connections limit is not being reached. This can be done by querying PostgreSQL’s pg_stat_activity view. For example, running a query such as SELECT count(*), state FROM pg_stat_activity GROUP BY state; will help you identify whether connection exhaustion is a recurring issue. If this is the case, scaling the Cloud SQL instance to a higher tier or optimizing connection usage through pooling may be necessary.

Addressing network and proxy configurations is another vital step. Verifying and adjusting TCP keepalive settings in PostgreSQL, such as tcp_keepalives_idle, tcp_keepalives_interval, and tcp_keepalives_count, ensures that idle connections remain active and are not prematurely terminated by network devices.

ALTER SYSTEM SET tcp_keepalives_idle = 30; -- in seconds
ALTER SYSTEM SET tcp_keepalives_interval = 10;
ALTER SYSTEM SET tcp_keepalives_count = 5;

This can significantly reduce connection interruptions caused by network timeouts. If you are using the Cloud SQL Proxy, ensure that it is properly configured and restarting automatically during disruptions. Additionally, review your VPC settings, firewall rules, and security policies for any recent changes that might disrupt database connectivity.

Implementing robust error handling and retry logic in your Django application is also critical for mitigating transient connection issues. For example, a retry decorator can handle database connection failures gracefully, retrying the operation a specified number of times before raising an exception. This ensures that minor network glitches do not disrupt the user experience.

Lastly, monitoring and logging key metrics such as connection establishment time, query execution time, and connection failure rates can provide invaluable insights into the health of your database. Google Cloud Monitoring (formerly Stackdriver) can be leveraged to centralize this data and set up alerts for abnormal patterns, enabling proactive troubleshooting.